Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner

I love this eyeliner because it's affordable and very easy to apply with a crisp line/wing. It isn't the liner I choose for long wear, because sometimes over a longer period (5+ hours) it transfers a bit from my lash line to my upper eyelid. I wouldn't call it particularly smudge-proof or waterproof, but that's fine for my everyday eyeliner. I've used many other eyeliner pens that were on longer usable after maybe 5-10 uses because they either dried up or the pen tip wore out too quickly and wouldn't make a crisp line. This pen lasts for a good while even with everyday use and even when I sometimes apply eyeshadow first before the liner.

LOOOVE, goes on great, long lasting. Natural. I've used many many different liquid liners. This one is the best hands down! I was wearing Stila but it would crack. At the crease (I wear cat eye, winged eyeliner) it wasn't working like it used to so I did some research found this brand, I tried a different one of these but it smudged. My lashes did look rejuvenated, so I kept looking at the brand and found the black magic liner. The BEST! The top is a thin brush easy to use dark color stays on all day with very little to no, creasing. Highly recommend! One thing I noticed when I buy it through Amazon it dries out fast, I've bought it from nordstrom. And eyko and never had that problem before, super weird.... 😐

I’ve been using eyeliner everyday of my life for 11 years. Literally no other eyeliner is as good as this one. I found it this year and it has changed my makeup life. I apply this eyeliner in the morning and it has lasted me days! And if I need a touch up, there is no problem with chunks of dry eyeliner getting in the way like other eyeliners have. It has also thickened my lashes after using it everyday. My eyelashes feel stronger than ever! When I remove my makeup I still think I have makeup on until I look closer and see it’s just my thicker lashes! Also, the pigment is amazing and super black. It has more of a matte finish which I absolutely love and if I layer it a lot it’s more of a vinyl finish. Please don’t ever change this formula, I hope to keep on buying this eyeliner forever!

TLDR: Not great for all day wear Good for lashes Not matte, shiny Fades quickly over time Not worth $26, but if on sale for >15, I'd go for it Better for your eyes, but not for your makeup look. Would I recommend it to a friend: honestly probably not. --- I apologize for the poor image quality, so to make it up to the reader, I didn't crop out my cat. Anyways, my first impression of this eyeliner was pretty good! Previously, I was using the NYX epic ink liquid liner, and I found multiple problems with it; so much so that I actually decided to throw it away before it was dried out, which is the first time I've ever done that with a product. I decided to "splurge" on an eyeliner, so I looked around a bit. I'd noticed with the cheap drugstore brands, my eyelashes were weaker. (When I would wash the makeup off my face, eyelashes were falling out.) So I wanted a liner that wouldn't hurt them, and also lengthen them. I don't like mascara and almost never wear it, so my lashes are what they are. After about a month of using this product, I've noticed a few things. 1. It's not matte, and it's not a full coverage black. I don't know if I missed that it was not matte, but it dries down rather shiny, sometimes making you able to see the skin underneath. Not a huge deal, but for the current price ($26) that's a huge deal for me, someone without a stable income. 2. Price. It is now listed at $26. When I bought it, it was $13.10. At the price I bought it, I would consider it worth it. At $26? No. There's probably something better out there. 3. Lash length. My lashes have grown a nice amount since I've started using this product. I don't see as much lash fallout when I go to wipe my makeup off in the evening. 4. Longevity. It's.... not quite there. I find that usually by the end of my day (7am-5pmish), it's rubbed off at the corner of my eye, and faded just about everywhere else. Granted, I am guilty of occasionally rubbing my eye, but the NYX eyeliner could always stand up to that, whereas I see a lot of transfer when I rub my eye wearing this liner. I hope this review helped! :)

This eyeko black eyeliner is my go to liquid eyeliner. Its easy to apply and stays all day with no transfer. A damp q-tip is all that is needed to touch up mistakes during application. It removes easily with make up cleansing cloths or eye make up remover at the end of the day. It does smudge if you rub your eyes directly, but doesn't otherwise transfer on my lids.

I have tried other liquid eyeliners, but keep coming back to Black Magic by Eyeko. The formula is thinner than some, so goes on very smoothly, like calligraphy, even as my eye lids begin to age, then it lasts all day. The real secret is in the incredibly flexbile, skinny, brush. I do have to be careful not to let any slide into my tear duct while it is still wet, but a quick q-tip solves that if it happens.

This was my go to eyeliner for a while but the past few I bought have been terrible. First time it happened I figured it was a fluke and bought more. That was a mistake. It doesn’t last as long as it used to both in terms of wear and running/drying out. One eyeliner used to last me months and would stay put all day. Now im lucky if I get 2 weeks and I don’t even use it everyday. If I tried to do a winged eyeliner, my wing is worn off in hours. Super disappointed that I have to find a new eyeliner

I love this product! I received a sample and now it’s the only thing I’ll use. The fine tip is amazing for drawing cats eyes and winged eyes. Once applied it doesn’t smear. I can wear it when I work out and it won’t fade, run, or rub off. I highly recommend this product.

Faccio un lavoro al sole, e nonostante che io sudi, questo prodotto non mi ha mai dato problemi, e in più il nero è un vero nero, non grigio scuro!

En dos meses ya estaba completamente seco y solo lo había usado un par de veces antes.

It was easy to apply on the eyelid just above the lash line, and it stayed on for at least 6 hours without smudging.

Da ich eine sehr tiefe Lidfalte habe und damit jeder Lidschatten und Eyeliner in der Lidfalte verschwindet und verschmiert ist es eh schwierig gut haltende Produkte zu finden. Egal ob billige oder hochwertige Produkte, ich habe schon alles getestet mit wenig Erfolg. Daher bin ich sehr begeistert von diesem Produkt. Er hält wirklich den ganzen Abend und verschmiert garnicht. Bin sehr zufrieden damit.

I love this product. I actually saw this on one of Alexa Chungs videos who seems to rave about how easy it is so I thought I would give it a go. It's great. Really easy to use as its like a pen, does not dry out and creates a lovely wing shape. The only thing I found is when it dried it became quite light and I like a very black liner but you can go over it again with ease to create a darker shade.